OnlyFans vs ManyVids: Comparison guide for spicy content Creators

Are you a Creator looking to maximize your earnings in the adult content industry?

Choosing the right platform is key to your success.

This guide compares OnlyFans and ManyVids, two leading platforms for spicy content Creators, to help you make an informed decision.

Quick summary:

• OnlyFans: Best for subscription-based content and mainstream appeal

• ManyVids is ideal for diverse monetization options and niche content. It offers more flexibility and fewer restrictions for Creators who specialize in niche content. 

In this guide, we’ll do a full comparison of the two platforms, diving into their features, payout models, site traffic, and overall user experience. 

Platform comparison: Comparing OnlyFans and ManyVids

Here's a side-by-side comparison of the key differences:

OnlyFans: The leading adult subscription platform for exclusive content

OnlyFans exploded in popularity, becoming a go-to destination for people who are looking for exclusive adult content.  

Think of it like Netflix for adult entertainment, where fans pay a monthly fee to access their favorite Creator's exclusive photos and videos.

According to this Tech Report article, there are approximately 120 million registered users on OnlyFans, with 2 million of those being verified Creators, making it the most popular porn subscription site globally. 

OnlyFans is best known for selling pornographic content, although they also host a variety of other content Creators, including chefs, fitness trainers, and musicians. 

Why OnlyFans is so popular for spicy content Creators:

• Direct connection: Fans can chat and interact directly with Creators.

• Exclusive content: Creators share photos, videos, and messages you won't find anywhere else.

• Support Creators: By subscribing, fans help support the Creators they love.

• Recurring subscriptions: Once you have a subscriber base, their monthly payments come in automatically, even if you don't actively create new content every day. This recurring revenue stream is a form of passive income. 

• Content longevity: Photos and videos can continue to generate income for months or even years as new subscribers join or existing ones revisit old content. 

• Automation potential: You can automate some aspects of OnlyFans, such as welcome messages for new subscribers or scheduled posts. 

OnlyFans Creators like Amara Tsuki have become very successful on OnlyFans, earning enough to make it their full-time job by having a free OnlyFans page.

ManyVids: A versatile marketplace for adult videos and live streaming

Every month around 25 million people visit ManyVids, a platform that lets you tap into your creativity and earn money in a variety of ways.

While OnlyFans revolves primarily around monthly subscriptions, ManyVids focuses more on content with a one-time fee. 

With options like on-demand videos, live streams, custom content, and physical merchandise, ManyVids gives adult entertainers a flexible platform to connect with fans and boost their income.

Running a ManyVids page is like running an online store. You need to constantly stock new products and attract customers to make sales.

What makes ManyVids special:

• One-Time purchases: ManyVids focuses on selling individual content, meaning each sale needs the customer to take action. With every video sold, you're trading your time for money.

• Live streams: Creators can host live shows where fans pay by the minute.

• Niche content: ManyVids has more relaxed rules, so spicy Creators can share a wider variety of content.

• Digital storefront: Creators can sell physical items and digital goods directly to fans.

• Advanced search functionality: ManyVids allows fans to search for content based on specific interests, making it easier to find exactly what they're looking for.

Features & functionality: Which platform offers more for spicy Creators?

Now, let’s compare the features that each of these sites has to offer. 

OnlyFans: User-friendly interface with essential tools

On OnlyFans, Creators can post multimedia content to their feed, message with fans, livestream to their audience and collect sales through subscriptions, tips, and pay-per-view messages. 

While it lacks advanced tools and automation, it allows Creators to manage content, interact with fans, and schedule posts manually.

Here are some of the platform’s key features:

• User-friendly interface: OnlyFans features a clean, minimalist design with intuitive navigation and a simple menu structure, making it easy for Creators to find and use essential features.

• Post scheduling: Offers the ability to schedule posts in advance.

• Limited options for diverse content types: Lacks embedded features for managing requests for custom content, so Creators have to take and price custom requests at their own discretion.

ManyVids: Advanced monetization and custom content options

Similar to OnlyFans, Creators can use ManyVids to host pre-recorded multimedia content.

But ManyVids offers a wider range of ways to make money. 

• On-demand content: Available on-demand content shows up on each Creator’s profile and can be accessed by paying a one-time fee. 

• Bundled content: ManyVids allows Creators to bundle premade content. Rather than selling all photo sets and videos separately, Creators can group content together to sell at a slightly discounted rate.

• Private shows: ManyVids allows Creators to do live streams and private shows where they set a per-minute rate and earn for the amount of time spent with a viewer. During these streams, performers can be tipped by viewers to earn extra cash. 

• Automated custom video requests: Creators can set the per-minute rate and include additional charges for creating custom content for fans by request. 

• Per-minute phone sex options: Phone sex sessions are also facilitated on ManyVids and are paid out following a per-minute billing system. If you choose to make use of the phone sex features, we recommend using a dedicated number using a service like Google Voice or Skype account to avoid leaking your personal cell number, since ManyVids may not encrypt these calls. 

• Digital storefront for physical items: Lastly, ManyVids allows Creators to sell physical items in a digital storefront, such as shoes or panties. Creators can list items available to purchase and then mail the item after ManyVids mediates the transaction. 

Earnings and payouts: Maximizing your income on OnlyFans vs. ManyVids

Both OnlyFans and ManyVids take a commission from Creators’ earnings in exchange for hosting and processing payments.

See below how OnlyFans and ManyVids payout structures compare:

OnlyFans payout structure: 80% earnings and flexible withdrawals

• Creator earnings: Keep 80% of your total revenue from subscriptions, tips, and Pay-Per-View (PPV) content.

• Platform fee: OnlyFans charges a 20% commission on all earnings.

• Withdrawal: You can request payouts anytime, with a minimum withdrawal of $20 (may vary by region).

• Referral program: Earn 5% of the referred Creator's earnings for one year, up to a maximum payout of $50,000.

ManyVids payout structure: Up to 90% earnings and diverse revenue streams

• First year earnings: Creators earn up to 90% of their revenue during the first year.

• After the first year:

  • 80% earnings for store items, text or phone services, and custom videos.

  • 60% earnings for video sales and memberships. For example, selling a $10 video earns you $6.

• Payout schedule: Payments are made twice a month (on the 1st and 16th).

• Minimum withdrawal: $50.

• Referral program: Earn 5% of your referred friend’s transactions for life, but this only applies to specific types of purchases.

Subscription models explained: Monthly Fees vs. one-time purchases

Both OnlyFans and ManyVids offer monthly subscriptions.

OnlyFans subscriptions

• Monthly subscriptions: Creators set a monthly subscription price, and subscribers pay this fee to access the Creator's exclusive content. Your OnlyFans monthly subscription can range anywhere from $4.99 to $49.99. 

• Free subscriptions: Creators can also offer free subscriptions but may charge for individual content or PPV messages.

• Bundles and discounts: Creators can offer subscription bundles for multiple months at a discount and also provide promotional discounts for new subscribers. The maximum price you can set for a bundle is $250. 

OnlyFans' monthly subscription model provides steady income and encourages customer loyalty, making it ideal for Creators who put out content consistently.

It let your make passive income but requires ongoing engagement to retain subscribers.

ManyVids

• Monthly subscriptions: This is the equivalent of a subscription on ManyVids. Creators set a monthly price for their MV Crush membership, which gives subscribers access to exclusive content.

• Membership perks: Depending on the tier, subscribers might get access to exclusive videos, photo sets, discounts on content, and direct messaging with the Creator.

• Club Trials: Gives fans access to the Creator’s catalogue for 24 hours.

• One-time Purchases: What sets ManyVids apart is the ability for fans to make one-time purchases of videos. 

Having a range of price points and content access options is appealing for potential buyers who might prefer one approach to accessing content over the other.

One downside, however, is that you might have to spend more time promoting your content if you don’t have a dedicated fanbase.  

Support & verification: Getting started smoothly 

OnlyFans verification process: What to expect

OnlyFans is notorious for having spotty user support. If a Creator needs help navigating an issue on the platform, they have to contact the support team via email.

OnlyFans is regularly criticized for slow response times, so many users turn to community info-sharing sites like Reddit for help coming up with solutions. 

The verification process on OnlyFans is tedious, and is known for rejecting accounts at random. 

To join OnlyFans, you'll need to:

• Confirm your email address

• Verify your identity with a valid piece of ID

• Fill in basic profile details

• Connect your bank account

It can take up to 72 hours for your account to be fully verified. If your application is rejected for any reason, you’ll need to correct it and resubmit, which may set the process back another 1 to 3 business days. 

ManyVids verification process: Quick approval and 24/7 support

ManyVids, on the other hand, has a live support team that’s active every day, around the clock, all year round. 

Support requests can be sent via email or digital form, and are regularly resolved within a 24-hour period. 

As well as having a reliable support team, ManyVids put a lot of work into having an informative help center with a detailed FAQ section and visual tutorials on how to troubleshoot common issues. 

To get verified on ManyVids, Creators have to:

• Submit a photo of themselves holding their government-issued ID

• Submit a note mentioning the date and their ManyVids username

It takes just 24 hours to get verified on ManyVids. If you have any trouble, the MV support team is available to help out.  

Moderation: Creating a safe environment

ManyVids has a list of forbidden words containing 91 terms that are banned for use in both uploaded content and messages.

Violating these rules will result in an immediate ban from the site. This protects Creators from receiving inappropriate or disturbing messages.

OnlyFans also has a restricted language list, although it isn’t available on the company’s website. If a Creator or subscriber attempts to use any of these words in a message or post, it won’t be allowed to send or process. Attempting to use these words in a roundabout way can lead to permanent account deletion. 

Both OnlyFans and ManyVids encourage Creators and site users to report any activity that goes against the sites’ guidelines.

Each site strongly prohibits disrespectful behavior, content piracy, scamming, and all other illegal activity.

Fetish content

OnlyFans: Restrictive for fetish content

Because of OnlyFans’ language restrictions around impact play terms like ‘flogging,’ ‘caning,’ and ‘paddling,’ as well as niche terms like ‘CBT,’ ‘fisting,’ and ‘restricted,’ fetish Creators will likely struggle to sell content on OnlyFans without violating the site’s strict guidelines. 

OnlyFans is a great match for Creators who create more mainstream ‘vanilla’ content.

Cosplay and fitness Creators also tend to succeed on the platform. 

ManyVids: More welcoming of niche content

ManyVids, on the other hand, has a designated MV Fetish page where niche Creators can showcase and promote their kinky content. 

Creators can choose up to 10 different tags and categories to label their content with, which helps subscribers easily locate niche content and explore new Creators by searching for specific terms. 

Here are some examples of niches that you may have trouble promoting on OnlyFans but which are allowed on ManyVids:

• BDSM

• Food play

• Impact play

• Urophilia

If a fetish isn’t already listed, ManyVids allows Creators to add their own, making it an extremely kink-friendly site. 

Security and content protection: Safeguarding your work

Both OnlyFans and ManyVids prioritize the security of their Creators' content and personal information.

They share several common features, including:

• Encrypted connections to protect user data 

• DMCA takedown support to combat content theft

• Proactive measures to scan the internet for stolen content 

• Secure storage solutions for Creators' videos and images.

But there are some security features that set the platforms apart:

OnlyFans' security features:

• Watermarking: Offers a free, customizable digital watermarking service.

• Geo-blocking: Allows Creators to control where their content is accessible.

• Comprehensive legal support: Notifies websites, hosting services, domain registrars, and major search engines of copyright infringements.

Check out the OnlyFans Privacy Policy for more info. 

ManyVids' security approach:

• Digital fingerprinting: Imprints all videos with a unique digital fingerprint ID for easier tracking.

• Encrypted streaming: Requires an encrypted unique signature for streaming or downloading content.

• Piracy prevention partnerships: Collaborates with major tube sites to block stolen content from being uploaded.

Learn more here.

Here are some tips for Creators to protect themselves:

• Use the geo-blocking feature when possible to prevent content from being viewed in your region. This can help you maintain privacy and security as an anonymous Creator.

• Watermark your content to deter unauthorized sharing.

• Regularly monitor your account for any suspicious activity.

• Use strong, unique passwords for your accounts and enable two-factor authentication when possible.

Want to learn more about how to stay safe when posting spicy content online? Read our article about OnlyFans safety. 

Discoverability and audience growth: Attracting more fans 

When choosing between OnlyFans or ManyVids, a key factor is how you'll attract new fans and grow your audience.

For OnlyFans Creators, building an audience takes more effort because the platform doesn't offer built-in discoverability features.

Promoting on OnlyFans: Leveraging external platforms

OnlyFans has extremely high site traffic, bringing in around 421 million visits globally per month. 

Despite these impressive statistics, Creators have no way to promote their pages through the site itself. 

This means having an OnlyFans account isn’t enough to gain exposure since there’s no ‘explore page’ or browsing feature. 

Creators are responsible for promoting themselves off-site on different social media platforms. 

Here are some ways OF Creators can promote themselves: 

• Use social media to your advantage: Platforms like X, Instagram, TikTok and Reddit are great tools to showcase your personality and content. Just be mindful of each platform’s content guidelines!

• Tease your content: Share snippets or teaser content that stays within the rules of each platform. A sneak peek of your OnlyFans content can entice potential subscribers to sign up for more.

• Build a community: Engage with your audience regularly across all platforms to build a loyal fan base.

• Collaborate with other Creators: This will help you cross-promote and reach new audiences. Infloww’s Share-for-Share feature makes it easier than ever to connect with other Creators. 

Promoting on ManyVids: Built-in tools and contests

While ManyVids may not be as popular as OnlyFans, there are lots of ways to promote your page using the site’s features. 

The two main features for gaining exposure through ManyVids are Ads and Contests.

• Contests happen on a weekly basis, with each one having a unique theme. Creators can send in their submissions—which are typically SFW-themed selfies—to be featured on a designated page. Each contest has a prize for winners, however, just participating in these events can drive traffic to your page. 

• ManyVids Ads are also an accessible way for Creators to gain exposure. Just choose a video from your site that aligns with their Content Rules, post its link, and include the hashtag #MVPromo in your post. The ManyVids team selects videos to promote on MV Social, their on-site social media feed, which functions similarly to X, based on ‘diversity, creativity and unicity’ at no cost to the Creator. 

Work less and earn more with Infloww

If you choose to go with OnlyFans, Infloww can help you maximize your profit while minimizing your effort. 

Infloww offers: 

• Smart fan engagement

• Powerful automation

• Streamlined content management 

Sign up for a 14-day free trial to try it out.

OnlyFans or ManyVids—Which platform is right for you?

Both ManyVids and OnlyFans offer distinct advantages and cater to different needs within the content Creator community. 

If you're a niche adult content Creator looking for more freedom with custom content requests, ManyVids might be your ideal choice.

On the other hand, if you prefer a subscription-based model with a mainstream audience, OnlyFans could be the better fit.

Ultimately, the best platform for you will depend on your specific content, audience, and business goals. 

Assess what each platform offers in terms of features, fees, and audience engagement opportunities.

By considering these factors, you can choose the platform that best aligns with your brand and maximizes your potential for growth and success.